Games / Guides / Strategy articles / Sea battle strategy
Sea battle strategy: find the fleet in fewer shots
Firing at random sinks a classic fleet in about 96 shots out of 100. A simple method gets that down to around 50, and careful counting does better still. Here's the method, the numbers behind it, and how to hide your own ships from players who know it.
The classic setup
In the classic fleet in Samphire Salvo, each side hides five ships on a 10 by 10 sea: a Flagship of 5 squares, a Cruiser of 4, a Frigate and a Submarine of 3 each, and a Patrol boat of 2. That's 17 squares of ship in 100 squares of sea. Ships lie across or down, never diagonally. You call a square, hear hit or miss, and you're told when a ship sinks and which one it was.
What our simulations show
We played thousands of simulated games against randomly placed classic fleets, with ships allowed to touch, to see how much each habit is worth. Here are the average shots needed to sink all five ships.
| Method | Average shots to sink the fleet |
|---|---|
| Random shots | about 96 |
| Hunt at random, then work round every hit | about 59 |
| Same, but hunt on a checkerboard | about 51 |
The biggest jump comes from finishing what you start. The next comes from hunting on a pattern instead of at random. Counting where ships can fit, which our hints show as odds on every square, gets you lower still.
Hunt, then target
Every game alternates between two modes. While you have no unsunk hits, you're hunting: spreading shots to find a ship. As soon as you hit, you're targeting: the rest of that ship is right next to the hit.
- After a first hit, fire at the four squares around it, one at a time.
- Once you have two hits in a line, you know which way the ship lies. Stop firing at its sides and follow the line to both ends.
- When the ship sinks, check your hits. If there are more hits in that area than the sunk ship covers, another ship is lying right alongside. Keep targeting there before you go back to hunting.
Why a checkerboard works
Every ship is at least 2 squares long, so every ship covers at least one dark square of a checkerboard pattern. Fire only at the dark squares while hunting and you're certain to find every ship, using half the shots that a square-by-square sweep would need.
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | • | • | • | |||
| B | • | • | • | |||
| C | • | • | • | |||
| D | • | • | • |
When the Patrol boat sinks, the smallest ship left is 3 long, so you can spread even wider: a pattern of every third square along each diagonal still catches every ship. In the quick fleet on a 7 by 7 sea, or once only the big ships are left, those wider patterns save a lot of shots.
Count where ships can fit
The best hunters go one step further. For each square, count the ways a remaining ship could lie across it without touching a miss or a sunk ship. The square with the most ways is the best shot.
You don't need to count exactly to use this. A few rules of thumb come out of it:
- Squares in the middle of open water fit more ship positions than squares on an edge or in a corner.
- A gap of two open squares between misses can't hold a ship of 3. Once only ships of 3 or more remain, skip those gaps.
- When the big ships are still afloat, long open stretches are where they must be.
- If ships can't touch, every sunk ship clears the water around it. Samphire Salvo marks that water for you.
Tap the light bulb in Samphire Salvo and you'll see a glow on every square by its chance of hiding a ship. Playing a few games with it on is the quickest way to build an instinct for where ships fit.
Where to hide your fleet
Good hunters fire where ships fit best, which means the middle of open water. So the edges and corners get searched a little later. That doesn't mean hiding everything on the rim: a player who notices will sweep it. The best fleets are hard to predict.
- Spread your ships out so finding one doesn't lead straight to the next.
- Don't line ships up end to end. A run of hits that keeps going tells the hunter there's more.
- Mix orientations, some across and some down.
- When ships may touch, two ships side by side can confuse a hunter into thinking one ship is longer than it is. It's a gamble, since one discovery reveals both.
Playing a salvo
In a salvo, you fire one shot for every ship you still have afloat, all at once, then hear the answers. Two things change.
- Spread your hunting shots. Two shots next to each other while hunting waste half their chance, because one ship would probably answer both.
- Your firepower falls as ships sink. Losing your Patrol boat early costs a shot every turn for the rest of the game, so protecting your fleet matters as much as hitting theirs.
- Mix targeting and hunting. With five shots, use two or three to finish a ship you've found and the rest to keep hunting.
Hit goes again
With the hit goes again rule you keep firing as long as you hit. That makes targeting even more valuable: a well placed second shot after a hit often chains into a sunk ship in one turn. It also makes ship placement more important, since one lucky hit can unravel a whole cluster.
Mistakes that waste shots
- Leaving a hit unfinished to go hunting elsewhere.
- Firing at the sides of a ship after two hits in a line.
- Hunting on a random pattern instead of a checkerboard.
- Firing into gaps too small for any ship left.
- Hiding the fleet in a tight group.
For the rules, fleets and the Daily Fleet, read our Samphire Salvo guide. For more two-player strategy with a little math, see our dots and boxes strategy and our four in a row strategy.
Questions
What is the best strategy for a sea battle game?
Hunt on a checkerboard until you hit, then work round the hit and follow a line of hits to both ends. Fire where the most ways a ship could lie cross.
Where is the best place to hide ships?
Somewhere unpredictable. Spread ships out, mix directions and avoid lining them up end to end. Skilled hunters search the middle first, but a fleet hidden only on the edges is easy to sweep.
Why fire in a checkerboard pattern?
Every ship is at least two squares long, so it must cover a square of the checkerboard. You find every ship with half the hunting shots.
How many shots does it take to sink a fleet?
On a classic 10 by 10 sea, random firing takes about 96 shots on average. Hunting on a checkerboard and finishing every hit takes about 51.











