Games / Guides / Strategy articles / Shut the box strategy
Shut the box strategy
Shut the box is a game of luck with a lot more choice in it than people think. Every roll gives you a decision, and over a few dozen boxes the players who decide well score clearly lower. Here are the odds behind the dice and the habits that make the difference.
The rules in a nutshell
A box holds nine tiles numbered 1 to 9. Roll two dice, then flip down any open tiles that add up to the roll. Roll an 8 and you might close the 8, or the 5 and 3, or the 1, 3 and 4. Keep rolling until no open tiles can make the total. The tiles left standing are your score, and lower is better. Close all nine and you've shut the box.
Many tables let you roll a single die once the 7, 8 and 9 are down, since one die can't make big totals anyway.
The odds of each roll
Two dice don't roll every total equally. There are 36 ways two dice can land, and the middle totals come up far more often than the edges.
| Total | Ways to roll it | How often |
|---|---|---|
| 2 or 12 | 1 | About 3 in 100 |
| 3 or 11 | 2 | About 6 in 100 |
| 4 or 10 | 3 | About 8 in 100 |
| 5 or 9 | 4 | About 11 in 100 |
| 6 or 8 | 5 | About 14 in 100 |
| 7 | 6 | About 17 in 100 |
That's the whole reason strategy exists. The 7, 8 and 9 tiles can only be closed by big rolls or by combinations that use up your small tiles, while your middle rolls arrive often. Plan around the totals you'll actually see.
Flip the big tiles first
The most reliable habit is simple: when you have a choice, close the highest tiles you can. If you roll a 9, closing the 9 is usually better than closing the 5 and 4. Big tiles are hard to close later and they cost the most if they're left standing, while small tiles are flexible and help you make awkward totals near the end.
Closing fewer, larger tiles also keeps more small tiles open, which gives you more ways to make future rolls. A box with 1, 2, 3 and 4 still open can make every total from 1 to 10. A box with only the 9 open can make exactly one.
Keep your options open
The goal on every roll is to leave a box that can make as many likely totals as possible. Before you flip, glance at what's left. Keeping a spread of tiles, like a 1, a 2 and something in the middle, gives you room to answer whatever the dice do next.
There are exceptions, and that's what makes the game interesting. Sometimes closing two small tiles keeps a middle tile that pairs nicely with what remains. When two choices look close, picture the next roll being a 7, the most common total, and choose the box that can still answer it.
When to roll one die
Once the 7, 8 and 9 are closed you may be allowed to roll a single die. Use it when your open tiles add up to a small total. If you only have the 1, 2 and 3 open, two dice will often roll more than you can make, while one die rolls 1 to 6 and gives you a real chance to finish. With bigger tiles still standing, two dice usually stay the better bet.
What a good score looks like
With the classic rules, even perfect play finishes a box at about 11 on average and shuts it close to one time in ten. So a 0 is a real achievement, a single digit score is a good box, and anything under 15 is a fine one. Judge yourself over ten boxes, not one.
Common house rules
- One or two tiles. Each roll may close at most two tiles. This makes the big tiles even more important to close early.
- Digit scoring. Open tiles are read as one number, so 1, 3 and 4 left scores 134. That makes the 1 the most expensive tile to leave.
- Always two dice. Without the one die rule, small boxes are harder to finish, so lean even harder on keeping small tiles open.
Play shut the box free
Pinewood Shut the Box is our shut the box game online, a pinewood box you can play free in your browser. Play solo for a best score, sit at the table against three friendly house players, or pass one phone around for up to four people. The Daily Box gives everyone the same dice for three boxes in a row, and a best flip hint works out, exactly, which flip leaves the lowest average finish, so it's a wonderful way to test your instincts against perfect play.
For more games with dice, see our dice games page, or try Foxglove Farkle and Pipfold.
Questions
What is the best strategy in shut the box?
Close the highest tiles you can on each roll, keep a spread of small tiles open for later, and roll one die once the big tiles are down and your open tiles add up to a small total.
What total do two dice roll most often?
Seven. It can be rolled six ways out of 36, followed by 6 and 8 with five ways each.
What is a good score in shut the box?
With classic rules, perfect play averages about 11 and shuts the box about one time in ten, so a single digit score is a good box.
Can I play shut the box online for free?
Yes. Pinewood Shut the Box is free in your browser, solo, against house players or pass and play, with a Daily Box and a best flip hint.
Game guides
More strategy articles
Liar's dice odds and strategyFibberfern Liar's Dice
How tennis scoring worksClover Court Tennis
Cornhole rules and scoringConeflower Cornhole
Archery scoring and aimingFeatherfield Archery
Go for beginnersAirscape Go
Darts 501 checkout tipsAirscape Darts
Jigsaw puzzle tipsMossnook Jigsaw
Escape room tipsKeyhole CottageYou might also like
10 minSavesFoxglove Farkle
FarkleRoll six dice, set aside the scorers and push your luck or bank. Real odds on every roll, Classic or Old style rules, five house players, pass and play, online with a friend and a Daily Posy.


